Chapter 048 - Either Or

I was sleeping when you telephoned;
said you're frightened when you're left alone.
I was welcomed by a TV blast;
should have seen it coming from your past.

You'll remember what I came here for
when you see me walking out that door
it's either or
it's either or
it's either or.

I've been waiting here to sell the farm;
filling forms with alphabetic charm.
Now you're saying I don't qualify;
should have seen it in your beady eyes.

You'll remember what I came here for
when you see me walking out that door
it's either or
it's either or
it's either or.

(spoken)
You told me to come on in for the big sale today,
and you told me to come on down to the front
and "be ye saved".
But I ended up spending more than I had ever planned,
and somehow, somewhere, someone led me astray.

I remember what I came here for;
can't you see me walking out that door
it's either or
it's either or
it's either or.

08/03/86


Either Or

One of Bobby's and my top 5 Apathy songs.  It has everything: a good guitar riff, an easy tune, good humming harmony background vocals, a spoken paragraph, an electric guitar solo, and some good rebellious rock and roll lyrics.  It's also one of those songs that took all of about five minutes to write, though we spent hours and hours improving it.  We recorded several versions, each one a little more innovative than the last.

The first verse is about the author’s old (made up) girlfriend.  The second verse is about Bobby trying to find a job after graduating from Western Michigan University.  In general, both verses are for anyone who's dealt with either an individual or an institution and couldn't get a commitment or a straight answer out of them.  What's it going to be, boy?  Yes or no? [Meatloaf]  Should I stay or should I go? [The Clash]  You can't have your cake and eat it too.  It's a great rock and roll theme.

1.   The author was always "on call" for this woman, very flexible, bending his schedule to find time for her.  He’s a little bitter.  Picture him getting a call from her late at night, begging him to come over.  When he arrives, he finds that she's fallen asleep in front of the blaring T.V. (the fuzzy screen that used to appear at 3am when televisions stations went off the air before cable TV came along).  He’s naturally disappointed.  She doesn't need him at all.  He should have seen this coming from her past history; it was there.

Chorus.   Make up your mind right now - no more vacillation.  Do you want the author or not?  If you can't treat him right, he’s out of there.

2.   Bobby filled out dozens of applications, sent letters and resumes, did interview after interview without success as did I when I was looking for my first job out of college several years before.  "Alphabetic charm" is all the B.S. one quickly learns he must fill his cover letters and resumes with.  The old Catch 22 comes up every time, "we need someone with experience".  But how does one get experience if he can't get a job?  The beady eyes are a dead giveaway that the interviewer is a banker, a bean counter.  Bobby was trying to get a job in a bank.

Release.  All we hear is promises and more promises.  The advertisers promise big, big savings at the stores while the T.V. preachers promise saving grace if we just "come on down".   In real life, one doesn't "save" money by going to the store and buying something one doesn’t need!  As has been shown many times, T.V. preachers can be the worst charlatans of all (Jimmy Swaggert, Jim and Tammy Bakker, etc.), wanting not much more from you than your money.  So this is a knock against them, not against real men of God who are really doing good works.






Music - Either Or (LP - PeeWee intro)

Music - Either Or (single)

One of Alex's favorite, we recorded her on lead vocal in 2015.  She also added harmony.

048c Either Or (Alex vocal)

In 2015 I was inspired to re-write the rebellious lyrics from the point of view of a famous Bible character - one of the most rebellious Jewish prophets - Jonah.  I used the song as a Bible study / devotion at a Christian camp for my daughter Veronica's class during her junior year of high school.  Those notes are below.  (I had also made a video montage to go along with the music.)

For this version, I'm singing lead vocals and for the long fade at the end I asked a friend from church, Travis Beck, to do the speaking part in his best Sam Elliott southern voice.

Music - Either Or (Travis fade)

Either Or

I was sleeping when you came to me
Said their lives were veering dangerously
I was working hard to block you out
Tried to run away and flame my doubts

Never thought that you would find me there
Never thought that you could make me care

It’s either or; It’s either or; It’s either or

Waves were towering over top of me
How to stop them came instinctively
Though I wasted my life fighting you
In the end I had to tell the truth

Never thought that life was fair at all
Never thought that I could make that call

It’s either or; It’s either or; It’s either or

I was waiting underneath a tree
Hoping you would come destructively
Didn’t know you had another plan
Gave them all a chance to understand

Never thought that I could see such peace
Never thought their souls could be released

It’s either or; It’s either or; It’s either or

SPOKEN DURING LONG FADE
Yeah, I was sleeping when he came to me
Woke me up - said they were out of control - said they were crazy!
I told him they meant nothing to me man
Got down to the port and got ready to leave the mainland
You won’t believe the massive waves that day
Seemed like a hundred feet high and everybody got down and prayed
Yeah, I wasted a lot of time fighting my own demons
Last thing I wanted to do was get involved with some heathens
But you know - - -  he was right and I was wrong
It doesn’t pay to fight the judge - in the end he writes the song

Holsem/Timmer
23-Nov-2016

 
A short look at Jonah

1. Common themes found throughout the Bible
a) We must choose good or evil, right or wrong, God or mammon (“Either Or”)
b) Israel was chosen by Jehovah to be a blessing to all the nations
c) God’s will is done - in the end - in every situation - with or without us

2. The anti-missionsary:
a) Jonah 1:2 – his mission
b) Jonah 1:3 – his reaction (Tarshish = “end of the earth”)
c) Jonah 4:2 – why didn’t he go?
d) Jonah 2:9 – rejoice in our own deliverance (but not that of others?)
e) Jonah 4:6 – rejoice that God answers our prayers (but not those of others?)
f) Jonah 4:3 – blinded by self rightousness
g) Jonah 4:10,11 – God is free to bestow His mercy on anyone, anywhere

3. Conclusions:
a) God’s will wins out – always – even when we don’t do the right thing
b) God chooses whom he wants to bless or save or forgive or pursue or …
a. Caution: it’s not up to us – God is sovereign – he created everything (the people, the storm, the fish, the vine, the worm)
b. Caution: the saved should not/cannot act self righteously
c. Caution: He might work among some group of people we look down on

4. The Song “Either Or” (old R&R song from the 80’s)
a) Old Testament rebel
b) Told from Jonah’s point of view
c) Conclusion is the lesson that Jonah should have learned (God chooses whom He saves)
d) Featuring a special guest from Explorer’s class on vocals
e) Video
a. Supposed to tell the story of Jonah with modern pictures, but …
b. Ran out of time – used family screensaver photos instead
c. Used many Mediterranean shots to give the right backdrop
d. Each photo has a literal or a symbolic meaning relative to the lyrics
e. E.g. I chose Nice, France (site of terrorist attack) as Ninevah





No comments:

Post a Comment